Evaluate The Effect of Post Prandial Exercise on Blood Sugar Level of Antenatal Mothers with Gestational Diabetes Mellitus at Women and Children‘s Hospital, Alappuzha
Mrs. Marie Rosy1, Mrs. Litty Stanley2
1Assistant Professor, KVM College of Nursing, P.B.No.13, Cherthala, Alappuzha -688 524
2II Year M.Sc. Nursing, KVM College of nursing, P.B.No.13, Cherthala, Alappuzha- 688 524
*Corresponding Author Email: rosyangel_07@yahoo.co.in
ABSTRACT:
The study investigated the effect of post prandial exercise on the blood sugar level of antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus. The Objective of the present study was to assess the fasting blood sugar and post prandial blood sugar level in antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus on the 1st and 6th day of post prandial exercise, evaluate the effect of post prandial exercise on blood sugar level, compare the level of fasting blood sugar and post prandial blood sugar on diet control group and insulin group and to find out the association between pre test of fasting blood sugar and post prandial blood sugar among antenatal mothers with selected variables. The study was based on General System Theory of Ludwig Von Bertalanffy. A one group pretest post-test design was adopted for the study. The sample size was 30 antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus admitted in Women and Children‘s Hospital Alappuzha, which was selected using convenient sampling technique. The tools used were structured interview schedule to assess the demographic and clinical variables, calibrated glucometer, procedure for post prandial exercise and check list for assessing post prandial exercise. Post prandial exercise was given 1hr 30 min after breakfast for 5 days and effect was assessed. The study revealed that the mean reduction in levels of FBS before and after intervention was 15.73 and the calculated t value 6.982 was significant at 0.01 level and the mean reduction in levels of PPBS before and after intervention was 22.17 and the calculated t value 5.096 was significant at 0.01 level. This shows that Post Prandial Exercise is effective in reducing the level of fasting and post prandial blood sugar among antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus. The chi-square value computed between pre test level of fasting blood sugar and previous information on exercise during pregnancy χ2= 3.913 was significant at 0.05 level. So the results shows that post prandial exercise is effective in reducing the level of fasting and post prandial blood sugar among antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus.
KEY WORDS: Post Prandial Exercise; Fasting blood Sugar; Post prandial blood sugar; Antenatal Mothers; Gestational Diabetes Mellitus.
INTRODUCTION:
Today‘s woman is one who wears many hats and is very expert at multi-tasking, at home and at work. And in this race to strike a balance, many often tend to ignore their own health and personal well-being. The growing fetus depends entirely on its mother's healthy body for all needs.
Consequently, pregnant women must take steps to remain as healthy and well nourished, should take into account the many health care and lifestyle considerations as they possibly can. Pregnancy is a diabetogenic condition characterized by insulin resistance with a compensatory increase in beta cell response and hyperinsulinemia.1 The placental secretion of hormones progesterone, cortisol, placental lactogen, prolactin, and growth hormone is a major contributor to the insulin resistance, which likely plays a role in ensuring that the fetus has an adequate supply of glucose.2
Exercise increases insulin sensitivity of muscle glucose transport and also enhances insulin action in extra muscular tissues.3 The three most important endocrine responses to exercise include a decrease in plasma insulin, an increase in sympathetic nervous activity causing changes in insulin counter regulatory hormones, and hormones affecting sodium and water balance.4
Planned physical activity of 30 min/day is recommended for all pregnant individuals excluding normal daily activities. Advising gestational diabetes mellitus patients to walk for at least 10 min after each meal accomplishes this goal. Regular aerobic exercise with proper warm-up and cool-down has been shown to lower fasting and postprandial glucose concentrations in several studies of previously sedentary individuals with gestational diabetes mellitus5. All women without medical or obstetric contraindications should be encouraged to start or continue a program of moderate exercise as part of their treatment for gestational diabetes mellitus.6Regular moderate-intensity exercise performed over the second-third trimesters of pregnancy can be used to attenuate important gestational diabetes mellitus-related adverse outcomes.7
The prevalence of GDM in India was 16.55% in the urban area and the frequency varied from 12% to 21% in different parts of the country.8 A low prevalence of gestational diabetes mellitus was observed in Kashmir 4.4% and a high prevalence of 16.55% in the southern part of India.9 Gestational diabetes mellitus is a severe and neglected threat to maternal and child health. Indian Diabetic Federation estimates that 16.8% of live births were affected by some form of hyperglycemia in pregnancy in 2013, and 6 million in India alone, of which 90% are due to gestational diabetes mellitus.10
India has the second largest number of people with diabetes in the world. Not surprisingly therefore, the prevalence of gestational diabetes mellitus in India is also alarmingly high. Indian women are more likely to develop gestational diabetes mellitus compared to Caucasian women.11 Estimates on the prevalence for gestational diabetes mellitus in India vary greatly; from low figures in the northern region of Jammu, to higher figures reported in the southern state of Tamil Nadu. In North Chennai, Tamil Nadu 891 pregnant women were screened and prevalence rate of gestational diabetes mellitus was found to be 16.2% , in south Chennai, among 1002 pregnant women, prevalence rate was 15% and in Erode out of 562 pregnant women, the prevalence rate was found to be 18.8%. In Ludhiana, Punjab, 220 pregnant women were screened and prevalence rate of gestational diabetes mellitus was17.5% and in Bangalore, Karnataka out of 49 pregnant women prevalence rate was 12% .12
Screening for gestational diabetes mellitus was done in different parts of Kerala. In Trivandrum, 750 pregnant women were screened and prevalence rate of gestational diabetes mellitus was found to be 15% and in Alwaye, out of 200 pregnant women, the prevalence rate was as high as 21%.12 These widely ranging statistics may reflect a true variation in gestational diabetes mellitus prevalence throughout the subcontinent, but may also be partially accounted for by discrepancies in protocols for screening and diagnosis, and access to care or changes in risk factors in different geographic regions.11 As more people in this country switch from heavy exercise routines, to health promoting activity programs, walking is emerging as a viable daily endeavor. Pregnant women who have been diagnosed with gestational diabetes mellitus may find that a simple walking program can keep their blood sugar levels under control, keep their body fat levels from increasing dramatically, and enhance their overall health.
Statement of the Problem:
Evaluate the Effect of Post Prandial Exercise on Blood Sugar Level of Antenatal Mothers with Gestational Diabetes Mellitus at Women and Children‘s Hospital Alappuzha.
Objectives of the Study:
a. Assess the fasting blood sugar and post prandial blood sugar level in antenatal mothers on the 1st and 6th day of post prandial exercise.
b. Evaluate the effect of post prandial exercise on fasting blood sugar level and post prandial blood sugar level among antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus.
c. Compare the level of fasting blood sugar and post prandial blood sugar among antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus on diet control group and insulin group.
d. Find out the association between pre test of fasting blood sugar and post prandial blood sugar among antenatal mothers with selected variables
Hypothesis:
H1- There is a significance difference in the blood sugar levels before and after the post prandial exercise among antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus as measured by glucometer.
H2- There is a significance difference in the blood sugar levels before and after the post prandial exercise among antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus who were on diet control and insulin as measured by glucometer
Theoretical Frame work:
The present study aimed at evaluating the effectiveness of post prandial exercise on blood sugar level of antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus. The theoretical framework of the present study is based on General System Theory with input, throughput, output and feedback. This model was first introduced by Ludwig Von Bertalanffy in 1968.
MATERIAL AND METHODS:
Research Approach:
The research approach selected for this study was quantitative approach.
Research Design:
The research design selected for this study was one group pretest post test design. The design showed as follows.
O1 X O2
O1- Assessing the level of fasting blood sugar and post prandial blood sugar before administration of post prandial exercise among antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus.
X - Administration of post prandial exercise to all antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus.
O2 - Assessing the level of fasting blood sugar and post prandial blood sugar on 6th day after administration of post prandial exercise among antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus.
Variables:
Three types of variables were identified in this study. They were:
Independent Variables:
The fasting blood sugar level and post prandial blood sugar level among antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus.
Dependent variable:
The post prandial exercise among antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus was the dependent variable.
Demographic variables:
It consists of baseline characteristics of antenatal mother such as age, education, occupation, diet, monthly income, gestational age, history of gestational diabetes mellitus, family history of diabetes mellitus and previous information about exercise in pregnancy.
Extraneous variables:
The extraneous variables in this study includes body weight, way of walking and daily activities of antenatal mothers.
Setting of the Study:
The study was conducted in antenatal ward of Women and Children‘s Hospital Alappuzha. It is a gynecological, obstetrical and pediatric specialty hospital with 306 bed capacity running under government of Kerala. This hospital provides all essential services under Directorate of Health Services. The hospital has got different facilities such as outpatient departments in obstetrics, gynecology and pediatrics, inpatient facilities such as antenatal ward, postnatal ward, gynecology ward, labour room, post-operative ward, pay ward, pediatrics ward, 24 hour casualty services, NICU, major and minor operation theatre, separate theatre for laparoscopic surgery, new born screening room, other facilities such as ultra sonography, laboratory, blood bank, pharmacy, ECG and 24 hours ambulance services.
Sample and Sampling Technique:
30 antenatal mothers, 15 on diet control and 15 on insulin in the second and third trimester with gestational diabetes mellitus in the antenatal ward of Women and Children‘s Hospital. Convenient sampling technique was used. On the average 3 samples were selected every day, until it reached 15 in each group.
Sampling Criteria:
Inclusion criteria:
1 Antenatal mothers were in 2nd and 3rd trimester and diagnosed with gestational diabetes mellitus in the present pregnancy.
2 Antenatal mothers who were on diet control for gestational diabetes mellitus.
3 Antenatal mothers who were on insulin therapy with Inj. Human Mixtard between 4units and 10 units daily.
4 Antenatal mothers who were willing to participate in the study
Exclusion criteria:
1 All antenatal mothers with non-compliance to exercises.
2 Antenatal mothers with disorders complicating pregnancy except gestational diabetes mellitus.
Tools /Instrument:
The data collection instruments used in the study was:
Tool 1: Structured interview schedule to assess the demographic and clinical variables of antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus.
Tool 2: Calibrated glucometer for assessing the blood sugar level on 1st day and 6th day of post prandial exercise among antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus.
Tool 3: Procedure for post prandial exercise among antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus.
Tool 4: Check list for assessing post prandial exercise of antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus.
Data Collection Process:
Data collection was done in the antenatal ward of Women and Children‘s Hospital. Based on the inclusion and exclusion criteria, 30 mothers were selected by convenient sampling. Everyday 3 samples were selected until it reached 15 in each group. The time of data collection was from 8am to 11am. On the first day, after obtaining an informed consent, demographic and clinical variables were collected from the antenatal mothers and fasting blood sugar and post prandial blood sugar level was checked. From day 2 to day 6, Post prandial exercise was given 1hr 30 min after breakfast. On the 6thday, fasting blood sugar and post prandial blood sugar level was checked and the blood sugar level on the first day and 6th day was compared to see the effect of exercise. There was cooperation in great measure from the samples and from the authorities of the institution throughout the study. This data collection process was concluded by thanking the samples and staffs in the institution.
Plan for Data analysis:
Section I Distribution of antenatal mothers based on socio demographic and clinical data.
Section II Assessment of fasting blood sugar level among antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus.
Section III Assessment of post prandial blood sugar level among antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus
Section IV Effect of post prandial exercise on fasting blood sugar level and post prandial blood sugar level among antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus.
Section V Comparison of the level of fasting blood sugar and post prandial blood sugar among antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus on diet control group and insulin group
Section VI Association between pretest level of fasting blood sugar and post prandial blood sugar and selected variables.
RESULTS:
Section I:
Table 1 Distribution Of Antenatal Mothers Based On Demographic And Clinical Data
Age in years |
f |
% |
x2 |
df |
p value |
18-22 |
7 |
23.3 |
3.858 |
3 |
0.277(NS) |
23-27 |
13 |
43.3 |
|
|
|
28-32 |
9 |
30.0 |
|
|
|
Above 32 |
1 |
3.4 |
|
|
|
Education |
|
|
|
|
|
No formal education |
0 |
|
|
|
|
Primary |
0 |
0.0 |
2.885 |
2 |
0.236 (NS) |
Education |
f |
% |
x2 |
df |
p value |
Secondary |
11 |
36.7 |
|||
Higher Secondary |
5 |
16.7 |
|||
Others |
14 |
46.6 |
|||
Monthly Income |
|||||
Below 5000 |
0 |
0 |
|||
5001 – 10000 |
17 |
56.7 |
|||
10001 – 15000 |
5 |
16.7 |
|||
Above 15001 |
8 |
26.7 |
1.236 |
2 |
0.539 |
Gestational Age in weeks |
|||||
13 – 28 |
9 |
30 |
|||
29 – 32 |
12 |
40 |
5 |
2 |
0.082 |
33 – 40 |
9 |
30 |
|||
History of GDM |
|||||
Yes |
7 |
23.3 |
2.779 |
1 |
0.096 |
No |
23 |
76.7 |
|||
Use of Insulin |
|||||
Yes |
15 |
50 |
1.677 |
1 |
0.195 |
No |
15 |
50 |
|||
Family history of DM |
|||||
Yes |
12 |
40 |
1.118 |
1 |
0.29 |
No |
18 |
60 |
|||
Previous Information |
|||||
Yes |
9 |
30 |
|||
No |
21 |
70 |
3.913 |
1 |
P<0.05 |
SECTION II: ASSESSMENT OF THE FASTING BLOOD SUGAR AND POST PRANDIAL BLOOD SUGAR LEVEL AMONG ANTENATAL MOTHERS WITH GESTATIONAL DIABETES MELLITUS.
Table 2 and 3. Percentage, Range, Mean, Median and S.D of antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus based on their pre-test and post test level of post prandial blood sugar level on 1st day and 6th day . n=30
Pre-test Level of FBS |
% |
Range |
Mean |
Median |
S.D. |
Less than or equal to Median |
56.67% |
88 – 140 |
102.33 |
98.0 |
12.696 |
Greater than 43.33%Median |
Table 3.
Post-test Level of FBS on 6th day |
% |
Range |
Mean |
Median |
S.D. |
Less than or equal to Median |
50 % |
60 – 125 |
86.6 |
85 |
13.22 |
Greater than 50%Median |
|
Table 4 N=30
Pre-test Level of PPBS |
% |
Range |
Mean |
Median |
S.D. |
Less than or equal to Median |
63.33% |
118 – 255 |
139.87 |
130 |
30.41 |
Greater than 36.67% Median |
|
||||
Post-test Level of PPBS |
% |
Range |
Mean |
Median |
S.D. |
Less than or equal to Median |
50 % |
98 – 172 |
117.7 |
117 |
13.72 |
Greater than Median 50% |
|
SECTION III : EFFECT OF POST PRANDIAL EXERCISE ON FASTING BLOOD SUGAR LEVEL AND POST PRANDIAL BLOOD SUGAR LEVEL AMONG ANTENATAL MOTHERS WITH GESTATIONAL DIABETES MELLITUS.
Table 5. Mean , S.D , Mean Difference , S.E and ‘t’ value of post prandial blood sugar level among antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus before and after post prandial exercise N=30
Level of FBS |
Mean |
S.D. |
Mean difference |
S.E |
df |
t |
p- value |
Pre-test |
102.33 |
12.69 |
15.73 |
2.25 |
29 |
6.982 |
p < 0.01** |
Post-test |
86.6 |
13.22 |
|
Table 6 Mean, Standard deviation, Mean difference, Standard error and „ t‟ value of level of post prandial blood sugar level among antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus before and after post prandial exercise
Level of PPBS |
Mean |
S.D. |
Mean difference |
S.E |
df |
T |
p- value |
Pre-test |
139.87 |
30.41 |
22.17 |
4.35 |
29 |
5.096 |
p < 0.01** |
Post-test |
117.7 |
13.72 |
|
|
|
|
|
SECTION IV COMPARISON OF THE LEVEL OF FASTING BLOOD SUGAR AND POST PRANDIAL BLOOD SUGAR AMONG ANTENATAL MOTHERS WITH GESTATIONAL DIABETES MELLITUS ON DIET CONTROL GROUP AND INSULIN GROUP.
Table 6. Comparison of The Level Of Fasting Blood Sugar And Postprandial Blood Sugar Among Antenatal Mothers With Gestational Diabetes Mellitus On Diet And Control Group And Insulin Group. N=30
Group |
Mean change in FBS |
S.D. |
Difference between means |
S.E. |
df |
t |
p- value |
Insulin |
22.4 |
13.75 |
13.33 |
3.83 |
28 |
3.479 |
p < 0.01** |
Diet control |
9.07 |
5.57 |
|
|
Table 7. Comparison of The Level Of Fasting Blood Sugar And Postprandial Blood Sugar Among Antenatal Mothers With Gestational Diabetes Mellitus On Diet And Control Group And Insulin Group N=30
Group |
Mean change in PPBS |
S.D. |
Difference between means |
S.E. |
df |
t |
p- value |
Insulin |
32.67 |
30.1 |
21.0 |
7.91 |
28 |
2.653 |
p < 0.05** |
Diet control |
11.67 |
5.81 |
|
|
|
|
|
LIMITATIONS:
The limitations of the study are;
1. The study was limited to 30 antenatal mothers with GDM
2. The study was limited to Women and Children‘s Hospital Alappuzha.
3. The study considered only one type of post prandial exercise that is walking.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
a) A similar study can be replicated with a control group
b) The study can be replicated on large samples.
c) A similar study can be conducted in rural area in the home setting.
CONCLUSION:
The present study assessed the effect of post prandial exercise on blood sugar level of antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus. Based on the findings, the following conclusions were drawn. Post Prandial Exercise is effective in reducing the level of FBS and PPBS among antenatal mothers with gestational diabetes mellitus.
REFERENCES:
1. Setji TL, Brown AJ, Feinglos MN; Gestational diabetes mellitus . Clinical Dabetes 23;17-24,2005.
2. Cianni GD, Miccoli R, Volpe L, Lencioni C, Del Prato S: Intermediate metabolism in normal pregnancy and in gestational diabetes. Diabetes Metab Res Rev 19:259–270, 2003
3. Richter EA, Galbo H: Diabetes and exercise. Int Diabetes Monitor 16:1–9, 2004
4. George .D. Harris, Russell. D, Diabetes management and exercise in
1. pregnant patients with diabetes. 2005 October Dio:10.2337/diaclin.23.4.165, Clinical diabetes, Volume 23No-4165168 URL http://clinical. diabetesjournals.org/ content/23/4/165 .full
2. 5.Boyd e. Metzger, Thomas A. Buchanan et al Summary and Recommendations of the Fifth International Workshop-Conference on Gestational Diabetes Mellitus diabetic care volume 30 2007 July 2;251-255
5. Annunziata Lapolla, Maria Grazia Dalfra, and Domenico Fedele, Management of gestational diabetes mellitus Diabetes Metab Syndr Obes. 2009 June; 2; 73-82.
6. Ruben Barakat,Mireia Pelaez et al Exercise during pregnancy and gestational diabetes-related adverse effects: a randomised controlled trial British Journal of sports medicine[Internet] 2012 September [cited 2013 92 January];[1-2] URL:http://bjsm. bmj.com/content/early/2013/01/29/bjsports-2012-091788
7. Seshiah, V.; Balaji, V.; Balaji MS.; et al. (2004). Gestational diabetes mellitus in India. J Associate Physicians India. Vol. 52, No. 9, (September 2004), pp. 707-11. ISSN 0004-5772.
8. Zargar, AH.; Sheikh, MI.; Bashir, MI.; et al. (2004). Prevalence of gestational diabetes mellitus in Kashmiri women from the Indian subcontinent. Dia Res Clin Pract. Vol.66, No. 2, (November 2004), pp. 139-45. ISSN 0168-8227
9. Women In India With GDM Strategy (WINGS), Indian Diabetic Federation, Chennai, India .Addressing the challenges of GDM detection and management in low resources-settings: A pilot project.URL: http://www.idf.org/women-india-gdm-strategy-wings.
10. International Diabetes Federation, Unite for diabetes 2013; GDM in India: Tackling a silent disease URL: http://www.idf.org/sites/ default/files/EN
11. Veerasamy Seshiah, Vijayam Balaji and Balaji Madhuri, Gestational Diabetes Mellitus - A Perspective ,Diabetes Research Institute, Diabetes Care Centre, India URL: http://www.intechopen.com/download/pdf/23173
Received on 30.08.2014 Modified on 29.09.2014
Accepted on 08.10.2014 © A&V Publication all right reserved
Int. J. Nur. Edu. and Research 2(4): Oct.- Dec. 2014; Page 350-355